Beware Unsolicited Parenting Advice Karma

On TodayMoms, Hoda Kotbe and Willie Geist talked to the Whatever Girls about how to handle unsolicited parenting advice.  One thing I cannot abide is people, especially people who do not have kids, telling me how to handle my own.  I have five kids ~ a stepdaughter who grew up in Texas with her mother (and visited every summer) and four kids who live with my husband and me.  My kids are now teenagers and every now and then when we go to the store I like to remind them of the speech that I used to give them when they were little people:

When we go into this store, do not touch anything and do not ask for anything.  If I buy you something it’s because I want to and not because you asked me to.  If you feel the need to touch something, put your hands in your pockets.  And, most importantly, if you embarrass me, I will embarrass you.  Now, let’s go shopping

I said that every time we went to the store until my youngest was 5 and the oldest was 9.  You see, I had four kids under the age of 5, I had to have control, they outnumbered me.  Every day there was a chance of a mutiny.

My kids responded to my little “pep talks” very well.  They’d go into the store and mind their manners.  Yes, there were a couple of meltdowns but, for the most part, we never had any real issues (I went through with my promise to embarrass them if they embarrassed me).  However, my sister~in~law, who did not have children at the time, used to question my discipline methods at every turn.  Every sentence began with “You should….”  or “My child would never….”  And all I could do was pray that some day she would have children.  I did flip out on her a couple of times, but there’s nothing like seeing someone go through the onerous ones, the terrible twos, the tantrum~filled threes and the frightful fours themselves.

Four years ago, my prayers were answered ~ she gave birth to a little boy.  I could not wait for this child to get old enough for her to have to start disciplining him because I was going to let her have it.  Well, let’s just say, I never got my chance because karma is a, well you know what karma is…  As her son got older and the temper tantrums became more frequent, I realized that I wouldn’t derive any pleasure from ripping into her.   She likes to tell me that it’s harder for her because she’s in her 40s with a preschooler.  Discipline is discipline no matter how old the parent or child is, and if you don’t have it, you have chaos.  I can’t wait for him to hit his teens…

This post was written as part of the Writer’s Workshop hosted by Mama Kat at Mama’s Losin’ It!

Related Posts with Thumbnails

I have the research skills of a librarian, the preservation skills of an archivist, the organizational skills of a mother and the domestic skills of a Stepford wife. I have the research skills of a librarian, the preservation skills of an archivist, the organizational skills of a mother and the domestic skills of a Stepford wife. Read more from this author


Tags: , , , , ,

  • Digg
  • Del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Twitter
  • RSS
  • http://www.peekatmypaper.blogspot.com Brenda @ PeekatMyPaper

    Hello Daenel
    Great post! I agree with you and love your little pep talk before you went shopping. That’s great!
    :)
    Thanks for stopping by Peek at My Paper and linking-up.
    I follow you on Monday Mingle and enjoy your Mingles.
    Good Luck with your 31DBBB Challenges!
    Brenda

    • Daenel

      Thank you. My kids laugh now when I give them “the talk.” My husband and I always said if you get control while they’re young, you’ll have less problems as they get older. Thank you for stopping by.

  • Daenel

    Hi, glad you’re enjoying my posts. I enjoy writing them. Discipline with love is the key to raising good kids. That and remembering that parents need to take time for themselves so they can recharge. Have a great week.

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention Living Outside the Stacks » Beware Unsolicited Parental Advice Karma -- Topsy.com

  • http://hisluckylady.blogspot.com debbi

    I have to admit I was one of those people before I had my son. Now, I have a completely different view! Great post!
    Happy SITS saturday sharefest!
    debbi recently posted..7-11- actually just 11

    • Daenel

      Hi Debbi, I think we were all guilty of giving out unsolicited advice at one time or another. It’s the ones who think they have *all* the answers that drive me insane. Have a great week.

  • http://mrstdj.wordpress.com MrsTDJ

    I’m an only child, the oldest cousin by many years and the first in my circle to have a child, so I’m on the receiving end of parenting advice from everybody and their mama! It is exhausting at times, especially when I get it from those parents whose own children aren’t shining example of successful parenting, ya know? I’ll be keeping my mouth shut in the future, unless asked. No unsolicited advice from me to anyone!
    MrsTDJ recently posted..A Room With a View

    • Daenel

      Oh, don’t you hate that ~ people who give out advice even though said advice doesn’t seem to be working out for them? Oy. Thanks for coming by.

  • http://www.myjobchart.com/l/blog-outreach/ Jon

    Yeah…..I was one of those. I would tell my older brother that he was disciplining wrong. To his credit he took it well, he would just laugh and say, “Just you wait….” I still don’t have children, but through blogs like this and some introspection I have realized that I was wrong, and when I see a struggling parent, I hold my tongue, and instead offer my hands to help in any way I can. Thanks for the post.
    Jon recently posted..If you register your site for free at

    • Daenel

      Jon, on behalf of all parents, thank you. LOL Sometimes a sympathetic glance goes a long way but a helping hand goes even further. :-)

  • http://deniseisrundmt.com Run DMT

    Great post! I think I was one of those people who knew how to parent without being a parent. I’m sure I made a few comments that made my friends and family members cringe. Then, I had my own children and boy, did I learn to keep my mouth shut! I’ve learned that you never say “My child(ren) never did that!” Those words will turn around and hit you upside the back of the head so quickly. I coined the expression Mama Karma for just those moments.

    http://deniseisrundmt.com/2008/08/01/mama-karma/

    Thanks so much for visiting my blog and leaving your comment. BTW…I love the title of your blog and you’ve got some great posts here. I’ll be back again. :-)
    Run DMT recently posted..On the Contrary- I Love My Children I Love My Life

    • Daenel

      “Mama Karma” I love it! It always comes back to bite you. I never offer advice unless it’s asked for that very reason. By the way, love your name. I saw “Run DMT” and gave a little chuckle.

  • http://www.randomlybitsandpieces.blogspot.com Michelle

    Don’t you just love it how people without kids are the experts? Whenever one of my kid-less friends or siblings talks about the how-tos etc., I just think, “mwa-ha-ha-ha,” cuz I know what awaits them. A lot of things in the “books” are easier said than done! And every kid is different. Thanks for the post!
    Michelle recently posted..I dont feel like working today

    • Daenel

      LOL The books are the worst! My kids never did anything by the books. I ended up tossing them by the time my first one was 6 months old.

© 2012 Living Outside the Stacks. All Rights Reserved. | Entries RSS & Comments RSS | Log in

Living Outside the Stacks is using WP-Gravatar

Switch to our mobile site